18 Most Common Mistakes Made By First-Time Home Buyers

Embarking on the journey of buying your first home is an exciting milestone, yet it’s fraught with potential pitfalls that can transform the dream into a daunting challenge. This blog post delves into the most common mistakes made by first-time homebuyers, providing insights and guidance to navigate the complex process of purchasing a home. From the oversight of consulting with only one mortgage lender to the pitfalls of emptying your savings for a down payment, we cover a wide range of errors that can jeopardize a buyer’s financial health and happiness. Additionally, we explore the consequences of not getting mortgage pre-approval early, underestimating the costs of homeownership, and the risks of making emotional decisions. By shedding light on these common missteps, our goal is to arm first-time buyers with the knowledge to make informed decisions, ensuring a smoother and more successful homebuying experience.

1. Talking to Only One Lender

One of the most common first-time homebuyer mistakes is consulting with only one mortgage lender. This single-lender approach can be limiting in several ways. Firstly, it restricts the buyer’s understanding of the diverse mortgage options available in the market. By consulting with multiple mortgage lenders, buyers can compare various loan terms, including interest rates, closing costs, and lender fees, ensuring they secure the most favorable mortgage rates and overall financial terms for their mortgage.

By talking to just one mortgage lender, buyers may miss out on better terms or more suitable loan structures offered by others. This oversight could lead to paying more than necessary, both upfront and in the long term. To avoid this mistake, consider consulting multiple lenders.

2. Not Starting the Approval Process Early

A loan application form with a section titled "About you" including fields for the applicant's address and postcode. The form has a red "APPROVED" stamp on it, indicating that the loan application has been accepted. There is also a blue and silver rubber stamp resting on the form, its handle visible and its stamping end resting on the paper.

Many buyers dive into house hunting with enthusiasm but overlook the critical step of getting pre-approved for a mortgage early in their journey. This oversight can lead to several complications. Firstly, without pre-approval, buyers do not have a clear understanding of their budget, which can result in setting unrealistic expectations or looking at properties that are financially out of reach. This not only leads to disappointment but also wastes valuable time that could be spent focusing on viable options.

Moreover, in a competitive housing market, not having a pre-approval letter can put buyers at a disadvantage when making an offer. Sellers often prefer bids from buyers who have already secured financing, as it reduces the risk of the deal falling through due to financial issues.

By not starting the approval process early, buyers may miss out on their dream home to more prepared competitors. Additionally, early mortgage approval gives buyers the opportunity to address any financial issues, such as improving credit scores or correcting errors on credit reports, which can affect the terms of the mortgage. In essence, initiating the mortgage approval process at the outset is a strategic move that empowers first-time buyers with financial clarity and a competitive edge in the housing market.

3. Emptying Your Savings

While it’s tempting to invest as much as possible upfront to reduce mortgage payments, this strategy can be risky. It often leads to buyers being financially overextended, lacking funds for unexpected expenses or emergencies post-purchase. Homeownership comes with unforeseen costs, such as repairs, maintenance, and property tax increases. Without a safety net, these expenses can lead to financial stress or, worse, debt accumulation.

Furthermore, depleting savings overlooks the importance of liquidity in personal finance. Life events, such as job loss, health issues, or family emergencies, can arise without warning. A healthy savings account is crucial to weather these situations without the added pressure of a mortgage. First-time buyers should aim for a balance between a reasonable down payment and retaining enough savings to cover several months of living expenses, including monthly payments for their mortgage. This approach not only ensures a smoother transition into homeownership but also provides a buffer against the unpredictable nature of life, safeguarding their financial stability in the long run.

4. Forgetting To Save For Closing Costs

Closing costs, which generally range from 2% to 5% of the home’s purchase price, encompass a variety of fees, including loan origination, appraisal, title search, and attorney fees, among others. These costs often catch first-time buyers off guard, as they tend to focus primarily on saving for the down payment. Neglecting to account for these expenses can lead to last-minute financial stress or, in worse cases, jeopardize the entire home purchase. It’s essential to understand that these are mandatory costs required to finalize the real estate transaction, and they cannot be bypassed.

To mitigate this mistake, first-time buyers should start their home-buying journey with a comprehensive budget that includes an estimate for closing costs. Speaking with real estate agents, lenders, or financial advisors can provide a clearer picture of these costs in the specific area and market they are looking to buy in. Some lenders even offer options to roll closing costs into the mortgage; however, this increases the loan amount and, consequently, the long-term interest paid.

5. Changing Jobs Before or During the Mortgage Process

A diverse group of professionals standing side by side, each representing different occupations.

Changing jobs can raise red flags for lenders, as it introduces uncertainty about the borrower’s income stability, which is a key factor in assessing loan eligibility. Consistent employment history demonstrates reliability and a steady income, factors that lenders heavily rely upon to predict a borrower’s ability to meet mortgage payments.

A new job, regardless of a higher salary, can be seen as a risk because it usually comes with a probation period during which the employment is less secure. This perceived instability can lead to delays in the mortgage process, less favorable loan terms, or even the denial of the mortgage application.

Moreover, job changes that involve a shift in the industry or a different form of income (such as moving from a salaried position to freelance or commission-based work) can be particularly problematic. Lenders typically prefer to see at least two years of consistent income in the same field or job type to assure the reliability of future earnings.

6. Closing Certain Lines of Credit

Closing existing credit accounts can negatively impact the buyer’s credit score, a critical factor that lenders consider when evaluating a mortgage application. This is primarily because closing old or unused credit lines reduces the overall available credit, which in turn can increase the utilization ratio – a key component of credit score calculations. A higher utilization ratio, indicating that a larger portion of available credit is being used, can signal potential financial stress or mismanagement to lenders.

Furthermore, closing long-standing credit accounts can shorten the average age of the buyer’s credit history. A longer credit history typically suggests more experience and stability in handling credit, making it a favorable aspect of the lending decision process. By shutting down these accounts, buyers inadvertently strip their credit report of this advantageous history.

7. Depositing Unsourced Funds

Lenders meticulously review a buyer’s financial history for stability and reliability, and any unusual deposits can raise red flags. These sudden influxes of cash can be interpreted as undisclosed loans or gifts, suggesting potential financial instability or additional debt obligations not accounted for in the loan application. This scrutiny is particularly intense in the months leading up to the home purchase, as lenders want to ensure that the buyer’s financial situation is stable and the down payment is legitimately sourced.

To avoid this pitfall, buyers should maintain a clear and consistent financial record in the months leading up to their home purchase. If large deposits are necessary, such as a gift from a family member towards the down payment, it’s imperative to have thorough documentation explaining the source of these funds. This documentation can include letters from the gift-giver, bank statements showing the transfer, or any other records that can clearly trace the origin of the funds. To avoid this mistake, ensure all significant deposits are transparent and well-documented, helping first-time homebuyers avoid unnecessary complications or delays in the mortgage approval process.

8. Not Seeking Advice From an Experienced Real Estate Agent

A smiling real estate agent holds up keys with a heart-shaped keychain, signifying a new home purchase. She is dressed professionally in a suit and holds blueprints or documents under her arm, indicating preparedness and competence in her role. In the background, a happy couple embraces, symbolizing their joy possibly at buying a new home, which is likely facilitated by the agent in the foreground. The focus on the keys and the agent’s smile suggests a successful real estate transaction.

Navigating the complexities of the real estate market without professional guidance can be akin to sailing uncharted waters without a compass. Experienced agents bring a wealth of knowledge about local markets, including pricing trends, neighborhood insights, and property history. They are adept at identifying hidden red flags in properties that may go unnoticed by an untrained eye, such as potential legal issues, structural problems, or zoning changes. By not leveraging this expertise, first-time buyers risk making uninformed decisions that could lead to costly mistakes or missed opportunities in finding their ideal home.

Furthermore, a seasoned real estate agent is not just a source of information but also a strategic partner in negotiation. They understand the dynamics of real estate transactions and can negotiate deals that align with their clients’ best interests. This includes navigating bidding wars, securing favorable terms, and ensuring a smooth transaction process.

First-time buyers may not be fully aware of the intricacies involved in negotiating real estate deals, and without an agent’s insight, they may end up overpaying or settling for unfavorable conditions. In essence, overlooking the value of an experienced real estate agent can lead to a more challenging and less efficient home-buying experience, underscoring the importance of professional guidance in this significant life decision. Avoid this mistake by consulting an experienced real estate agent.

9. Expecting to Find a Perfect Home

A pervasive and often costly mistake made by first-time homebuyers is the pursuit of a ‘perfect’ home. This quest for an ideal property, which ticks every box on their wish list, can lead to prolonged searches, increased expenses, and ultimately, disappointment. The reality of the real estate market is that it’s rare to find a home that perfectly aligns with all your preferences, needs, and budget constraints.

This expectation can be particularly limiting in competitive markets, where the available inventory may not meet idealized standards. By fixating on finding a flawless home, buyers risk overlooking properties that, while not perfect, could be excellent fits with potential for customization or future upgrades.

It’s crucial for first-time buyers to approach the home-buying process with flexibility and a willingness to compromise. Prioritizing core needs over desirable but non-essential features is key. For instance, focusing on location, structural integrity, and the number of bedrooms or bathrooms should take precedence over aesthetic elements like countertop materials or flooring types, which can be changed over time. To avoid this mistake, maintain flexibility and prioritize core needs.”

10. Making Emotional Decisions

a home is not just a financial investment but also an emotional one, and it’s natural for first-time buyers to get attached to a property. However, this attachment can cloud judgment and lead to overlooking practical aspects such as the home’s condition, location, and price.

Emotional decisions may cause buyers to rush into offers without thorough consideration, often resulting in overpaying or investing in a property that doesn’t meet their long-term needs. The charm of a dream kitchen or the appeal of a cozy backyard can distract from potential issues like poor plumbing, structural problems, or a neighborhood that doesn’t fit their lifestyle. Avoid this mistake by staying objective and considering all factors.

11. Buying More House Than You Can Afford

A charming two-story house featuring a mix of stone and shingle siding, with a prominent gable roof and multiple windows.

Often driven by emotion or the allure of a dream home, buyers can overlook the practicalities of their financial situation, leading to the crucial question of how much house they can actually afford. This mistake goes beyond the initial strain of a hefty down payment; it encompasses the long-term ramifications of managing higher monthly mortgage payments, property taxes, insurance, maintenance, and unexpected repairs. The consequences of overextending financially can be dire, leading to a precarious living situation where even minor changes in income or unforeseen expenses can result in financial distress or, in the worst-case scenario, foreclosure.

It’s essential for first-time buyers to adopt a pragmatic approach when determining their budget, which should include a careful evaluation of their debt-to-income ratio. This ratio assesses current income against existing debts; a critical measure lenders use to determine loan eligibility and financial stability, alongside considering savings and future financial changes and responsibilities. A common rule of thumb is to aim for a property where the monthly mortgage payment does not exceed 28% of gross monthly income.

Additionally, it’s wise to factor in lifestyle and savings goals. Overspending on a house can severely restrict the ability to save for retirement, children’s education, or even just the flexibility for leisure and travel. Remember, a dream home should provide a sense of security and comfort, not a financial burden that limits life’s other pleasures and necessities.

12. Underestimating the Costs of Homeownership

A critical error often made by first-time homebuyers is underestimating the full spectrum of costs associated with homeownership. Beyond the initial price tag of the house, there are numerous ongoing expenses that can take new homeowners by surprise. Property taxes, homeowners’ insurance, and, potentially, homeowners association (HOA) fees can add a substantial amount to the monthly costs.

Furthermore, the costs of maintenance and repairs are frequently overlooked. Unlike renting, where the landlord typically covers major repairs, homeowners are solely responsible for all upkeep. This can include everything from minor repairs, like fixing leaky faucets, to significant expenditures, such as replacing a roof or updating an HVAC system.

These costs can add up quickly and are often unpredictable, making it essential for first-time buyers to set aside a contingency fund for these eventualities. By recognizing and preparing for these additional costs, first-time homebuyers can make more informed decisions and avoid financial pitfalls that might otherwise compromise their homeownership experience.

13. Miscalculating Repair and Renovation Costs

A smiling man wearing a blue cap and gray shirt is standing on a yellow stepladder outside a house with white siding. He is holding a tool tray filled with various items, suggesting he is engaged in home repair or maintenance work.

Novice buyers may fall in love with a property that requires significant work, overlooking the reality of the extensive costs and time required to make it livable or to their liking. They might base their budget on superficial estimates or popular home renovation shows, failing to account for the hidden, unpredictable expenses that frequently arise once the work begins. These can include structural repairs, electrical upgrades, or plumbing overhauls, which are not only costly but may also be essential for safety and functionality.

Furthermore, first-time buyers might not realize the full extent of the costs of even minor renovations. Simple updates like painting, changing fixtures, or minor landscaping can quickly become expensive, especially when professional help is needed. This underestimation can lead to financial strain, as the budget set aside for these updates falls short, forcing homeowners to either live in a partially renovated space or stretch their finances thin.

14. Waiting to Buy Until You’ve Saved for a 20% Down Payment

A prevalent misconception among first-time homebuyers is the belief that they must save up for a 20% down payment before purchasing a property. While a 20% down payment can help avoid private mortgage insurance (PMI) and potentially secure more favorable loan terms, it is not a strict necessity for buying a home. In reality, waiting to accumulate this amount can unnecessarily delay homeownership and potentially cost buyers more in the long run.

Housing markets generally appreciate over time, meaning prices could rise significantly while buyers are saving, ultimately making homes less affordable. Moreover, the opportunity cost of waiting includes continuing to pay rent, which doesn’t contribute to building equity in a property.

15. Ignoring VA, USDA, and FHA Loan Programs

A significant oversight many first-time homebuyers make is overlooking government-backed loan programs such as those offered by the Veterans Affairs (VA), U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), and Federal Housing Administration (FHA). These programs are specifically designed to assist various categories of buyers in achieving their dream of homeownership.

VA loans, for instance, offer tremendous benefits to military service members and veterans, including no down payment requirements and competitive interest rates. Similarly, USDA loans are targeted toward buyers in rural and certain suburban areas, offering 100% financing and reduced mortgage insurance costs. FHA loans, known for their lower down payment requirements and more lenient credit score criteria, are particularly advantageous for buyers who might struggle to qualify for conventional loans.

Ignoring these options can result in first-time buyers missing out on potentially more favorable loan terms that could make homeownership more affordable and accessible. Many assume these loans are overly complex or come with hidden drawbacks, but in reality, they can offer unique advantages not available through conventional lending. For instance, lower down payments and more flexible credit requirements can make a significant difference in a first-time buyer’s budget and loan eligibility.

16. Waiving A Home Inspection

home inspection

Waiving a home inspection is a significant mistake often made by first-time homebuyers, particularly in competitive real estate markets where they feel pressured to make their offer more appealing to sellers. However, this decision can have costly repercussions. A home inspection is a crucial step in the buying process, as it provides an in-depth look at the property’s condition, revealing potential issues that may not be visible during a standard viewing.

These issues can range from minor cosmetic flaws to major structural problems, electrical issues, or plumbing concerns, which can be expensive to repair. By waiving the inspection, buyers risk inheriting these hidden problems, leading to unexpected and often substantial financial burdens after the purchase.

Furthermore, the insights gained from a home inspection can be invaluable in negotiating the final purchase price. If the inspection uncovers significant problems, buyers have the leverage to request repairs, a reduction in the sale price, or even back out of the deal if the issues are too severe. This critical information arms buyers with the knowledge needed to make an informed decision about their investment.

17. Not Researching The Neighborhood


Important aspects to investigate include local crime rates, the quality of nearby schools, access to amenities such as parks, hospitals, and shopping centers, as well as the general vibe and culture of the community. Ignoring these elements can lead to dissatisfaction with the living environment or, worse, a decrease in the property’s value over time.

Moreover, not researching the neighborhood can lead to unforeseen complications. For example, areas prone to natural hazards like flooding or wildfires might require additional insurance, which can add to the overall cost of homeownership. Local zoning laws and future development plans can also affect a property’s surroundings and value. Engaging with local residents, visiting at different times of the day, and consulting online community forums can provide invaluable insights.

18. Ignoring The Rules Of The HOA

HOAs can have a significant impact on your living experience and personal freedoms in your new home. These associations often have strict guidelines regarding exterior home modifications, landscaping, pet ownership, noise levels, and even parking regulations. Failing to adhere to these rules can lead to fines, legal disputes, and in extreme cases, forced compliance or litigation. First-time buyers should thoroughly review the HOA’s covenants, conditions, and restrictions (CC&Rs) before committing to a purchase. This ensures they are comfortable with the level of control the HOA exerts over their property and lifestyle.

Additionally, it’s vital to consider the financial implications of HOA fees. These fees, which can be substantial, are used for maintaining common areas, amenities, and sometimes even certain utilities or services. However, they also add to the monthly costs of homeownership, which can be a strain on budgeting, especially for those new to the real estate market.

Start Your Nashville Home-Buying Journey with Bernie Gallerani Real Estate

As you embark on your journey to homeownership, remember that the path is filled with important decisions and potential obstacles. Armed with the knowledge of common mistakes to avoid, you’re one step closer to making an informed and confident home purchase.

If you’re looking to buy in the Nashville area, don’t navigate this complex process alone. Contact Bernie Gallerani Real Estate for expert guidance and support. Our team is dedicated to helping you find your dream home while avoiding the pitfalls that can trap first-time buyers.

Let us be your partner in this exciting journey, providing you with the insight and expertise needed to make your home-buying experience as smooth and successful as possible. Contact Bernie Gallerani Real Estate today and take the first step towards securing your first home.

Get Your Home Value in Seconds Without Talking to an Agent

Scroll to Top
Bernie Gallerani